Which Payment Provider Should I Use? Quiz for SaaS and Digital Products

Answer 6 quick questions and get your top 3 matches, ranked and explained.

Which payment provider should I use for my SaaS?

Start with who handles sales tax and VAT. If you'll register and file it yourself, a payment gateway is cheapest: Stripe charges 2.9% + $0.30 and Braintree 2.89% + $0.29. If you want the provider to be the legal seller and handle tax for you, choose a merchant of record such as Paddle (5% + $0.50), Creem (3.9% + $0.40) or Lemon Squeezy (5% + $0.50). After that, chargeback cover, dunning, license keys and affiliate tools decide between the remaining options.

Answer the six questions below to get your top 3, with the fee on your own transaction size.

Rates last checked against official pricing pages on

Example quiz results

Three common setups run through the quiz. Each shows the real top 3 it returns, the points scored and the fee per charge.

Indie SaaS selling worldwide

SaaS, international customers, provider handles tax, wants chargeback cover and dunning, no add-ons. $29 charge, 300 a month.

1. Freemius (6 pts)
$1.36 fee (4.7%), est.
2. Creem.io (5 pts)
$1.53 fee (5.3%)
3. PayPro Global (4 pts)
$1.92 fee (6.6%), est.

Choosing "handle it for me" removes Stripe and Braintree. Most merchants of record tie on these features, so the fee on a $29 charge decides the order. Freemius and PayPro Global are ranked on typical quoted rates, so check your own quote.

US SaaS that files its own sales tax

SaaS, mostly domestic customers, handles tax itself, no need for chargeback cover or add-ons. $100 charge, 100 a month.

1. Braintree (6 pts)
$3.18 fee (3.2%)
2. Stripe (5 pts)
$3.20 fee (3.2%)
3. 2Checkout (1 pt)
$3.85 fee (3.9%)

Gateways get 3 points when you handle tax yourself, and they also take the cheapest fee slots. Braintree and Stripe are $0.02 apart on a $100 charge, so pick on developer tools and payouts rather than price.

Global SaaS that wants chargeback cover

SaaS, international customers, handles tax itself, wants chargeback cover, dunning and affiliate tools. $50 charge, 200 a month.

1. Braintree (7 pts)
$2.24 fee (4.5%)
2. Freemius (6 pts)
$2.35 fee (4.7%), est.
3. Creem.io (5 pts)
$2.35 fee (4.7%)

Braintree wins on the gateway bonus and price but misses 3 of your requirements. Freemius and Creem.io cover them for a little more per charge. That is the gateway vs merchant of record trade-off in one result.

Assumptions and limitations

  • The quiz scores 13 providers with fixed rules, not a model. Handling tax yourself gives pure gateways 3 points. Each feature you ask for (localized checkout, chargeback cover, dunning, affiliates, license keys) adds 1 point to providers that have it.
  • Choosing "handle tax for me" removes gateways from the results entirely, since they don't act as merchant of record.
  • Unless you skip the numbers step, the three cheapest providers for your transaction size get 3, 2 and 1 bonus points. Ties are broken by the lower fee.
  • Fees use each provider's standard one-time card rate, plus its international surcharge if you sell abroad. Subscription surcharges (such as Stripe Billing's 0.7%), PayPal, BNPL, currency conversion and tax tools are not included.
  • PayPro Global, FastSpring and Freemius quote custom rates. The quiz ranks them on typical rates (4.9% + $0.50, 5.9% + $0.95 and 4.7%) and marks them as estimated.

Sources

Last checked on . Providers change pricing without notice - confirm on their site before you switch.

Frequently Asked Questions

Ministry of Economy and Innovation
Startup Albania

The Chartsy program is realized with the financial support of the Albanian Government through the Ministry of Economy and Innovation, under the Grant 2026 scheme, and is implemented by the Innovation4Albania Agency.